N-Backing & MindSparke-ing: What it is, why you should do it.
All About N-Back
Sometime last year, I read about a somewhat confusing, yet convincing technique of brain training, complete with a rather unfriendly name that only a scientist mother could love: “The Dual Task N-Back“.
The name amounts to a mathematical description of the actual task: The “dual” part refers to audio and visual elements of the task. “N” is a variable whole number. Add in the “back” bit, and you begin to realize this is about identifying those audio/visual elements that match those shown N many elements back from the current one. (Does this sound a bit like the new season of LOST to anyone else? No? )
And no, it isn’t any easier to do n-back tests than it is to explain them
But here’s the impressive bit: training with this method appears to increase fluid intelligence.
In a limited trial, 34 subjects trained with dual n-back exercises for 25 minutes a day, for 19 days… they were given IQ tests at the beginning and the end of the trial period. The results? An astounding average increase in performance on an IQ test, markedly better than the control group.
These results had the brain fitness folks really buzzing when the report came out, and for good reason. Ordinarily, training in task-related tests only improves performance on that particular (or related) task. But the n-back method appears to have increased mental function in a broader way. The researchers speculate that the n-back task perhaps increases working memory, attention span and/or focus, but it’s too early to be certain exactly what’s behind the improvement, or how long it sticks around.
And That Brings Us To MindSparke
Mind Sparke is a non-nonsense, straight-forward software implementation of the dual N-back training protocol based on the research study mentioned above.
This is some serious brain training, folks - no chirping birds, roaring monsters or whining penguins included. The user interface is purely functional, without so much as a fancy font or drop shadow to distract you. The only color to be found is if you opt to display your keystrokes - a little red or blue A for audio, V for visual will appear.
The visual stimulus is simple squares that show up as white on black. The voices that pronounce the audio portion (letters from the alphabet) are a nondescript but pleasant enough male and female.
The results of each block is displayed on the “home” screen, so as you progress through each session, you’ll see your hits, misses, and the current value of “N” — which will change according to your success level. Your improvement over time is displayed as a graph on the “history” screen. (I haven’t gotten far in my own training, so the graph below is a screen shot grabbed from the MindSparke website. )
There is no demo version of MindSparke available, and for good reason… n-back training is very challenging, even frustrating at first.
It’s tough to imagine someone downloading a trial, doing a few blocks and saying WOW I want this! It takes a bit of discipline and determination to get through those first few sessions. But there is a pretty impressive money back guarantee offered on the website…
If after 10 days you don’t notice a difference in the clarity, speed and power of your thinking we’ll give you a full refund plus $40 toward another brain fitness product of your choice.
Not bad at all!
How The Program Works
The software will walk you through 19 sessions, of 20 blocks each. Each block contains a number of different position and letter combinations. When you see a match, you type the letter A…. when you hear a match, you type the letter L.
When it begins, you’ll start with n equal to 2, meaning you’ll be matching items 2 places back. For example, you might hear the letters “B G A F G F B”. With n=2, you’d hit the L key when you heard the second F, because the letter F matches 2 places back.
Once you’ve had success with n=2, the program will automatically step you up to n=3. Now, hearing those same letters, you’d hit the L key on the second G: “B G A F G F B” because the G is a match for the letter 3 places back.
The software will automatically adjust the difficulty up and down according to your performance, and the current n= value will be displayed on screen at all times. Each block takes ___ minutes, each session about ____ (depending on how long you break between blocks).
Confused? Yeah, me too. But it makes more sense when you start actually working with the program.
So, Why Should You N-Back?
This is a different sort of brain training. It’s intense, focused, and very challenging, and the benefits appear to be pretty remarkable. Outside of the original study and the associated improvement on IQ tests, users of MindSparke seem to be reporting that it helps their mental focus and attention significantly.
So if you’re intrigued by the concept of formal brain-training programs, but find the game-centric industry a bit too light and fluffy for your taste - give this approach a whirl.
MindSparke should appeal to more science-centric MindTweakers, as well as to choleric, no-nonsense personalities who have had enough of cutesy brain games. I also suspect that MindSparke is well suited for younger, more mentally active folks, who may not feel challenged enough by programs targeted towards seniors.
It’s affordably priced at $46.95 for the download version, and a hardcopy on CD is available for an additional $9.95.
I’ll be writing up more personal successes and struggles I’ve had with n-backing in a day or so… but for now, you can go and read Erin’s experiences over at Brain Training 101. She’s nearly through her 19 days, and is seeing pretty remarkable results. (While you’re there, be sure and check out her interview with MindSparke founder, Martin Walker)
You can check out the software and website here:
Mind Sparke Brain Fitness Pro - Software that makes you smarter
______________________________________________
MindTweak: “Our brightest blazes are commonly kindled by unexpected sparks.” - Samuel Johnson
______________________________________________
Note For The Transparency Concerned Among Us: Yes, the above article contains affiliate links. No, that did not trigger my review (though personal contact with Martin Walker did). I’ve found that affiliate links do not influence or change my reviews - with one notable exception: I’ve got an odd tendency to bridle my enthusiasm for products once I’m an affiliate.
Seems I’m afraid I’ll sound too salesy - and it’s stifling my naturally enthusiastic voice somewhat. As a result, I’m not sure what the future of affiliate programs is here, but I’m going to give it a good try, first.







{ 7 comments… read them below or add one }
That is a great explanation of what the heck n-back even means. When I first read the study, I could not get my head around how it worked. When I first read the instructions to Mind Sparke (multiple times no doubt), I also could not figure it out.
It’s one of those things that you have to work through a couple of times and then one day it just becomes clear.
I’m looking forward to your thoughts as you continue through the training. It’s good to see the different takes.
@Erin… It was a struggle to try and explain it! I’d read the original study, several articles about it, and I just didnt grasp it either. Finally, after *doing* it, I found words that I hope others will understand. A less technical name would help…. How Many Sounds Back? or something.
And it is interesting to see the different takes on this and other programs. The more I look into Brain Fitness, the more individually tailored it seems that it MUST be. All of the ‘one size fits all’ solutions (whether they are pro or con whatever method) just don’t seem all that certain to be a fit!
Whoa! Nothing like jumping in the deep end. Confused yes. I am going to get my brain back in work mode before I attempt to understand. Cheers to you for explaining it.
A free version of the same software (since the scientists who invented the software are not making any money out of it so why should anyone else?) can be found in http://brainworkshop.sourceforge.net/
Have fun
Hi George,
Thanks for the link to the open source N-Back program, I appreciate it!
But I’m puzzled by the “why should anyone else make money” snark. Open source projects rock (Clearly I’m a fan, I use Wordpress!) but commercial products have their place too, and believe it or not, many people like the reassurance of knowing the code is trusted and supported by a company with something to lose.
And there may be a little confusion - “software” and “protocol” are different. The scientists came up with the protocol (the actual dual N-Back exercise) but MindSparke and the other folks independently developed their own software applications… a costly and difficult endeavor. They aren’t somehow “ripping off” the scientists, and it’s not “wrong” for companies to develop and market products based on scientific studies - that’s how the system works, and keeping the market and the research separate helps maintain scientific integrity.
In the case of MindSparke, I’m pretty darn confident that the intent was to help people, and make sure the protocol was available to for the public to use. The founder is one of the most generous, thoughtful and kind people I’ve met in an industry filled with generous, thoughtful and kind people.
BTW, after a long wait - the University of Bern has finally released their own version of the protocol to the public in their “Brain Twister Suite” for about $60. So if you want to be annoyed on behalf of the scientists — you should be even more annoyed at the freeware versions that compete with it
As well as the OpenSource project you mentioned, there are web applications here: SoakYourHead’s DualNBack Web App and here Dual n-back task
But bottom line - the more versions of this sort of exercise are available, the more highly promoted it is, the more the public becomes “aware” of it, the better off we ALL are, as a society.
Hi Tori.
Thank you for such a cogent response to George’s comment. I certainly am in this business to try to help people, and since I’m not independently wealthy with time on my hands I chose to do that by creating a product worth purchasing. The other dual n-back exercises you mention are great, but they’re not for everyone. We have plenty of customers who have been very happy to purchase Brain Fitness Pro after trying the shareware versions or purchasing Brain Twister.
We take great care to make sure that each customer derives value and achieves his or her goals. This takes careful design and in some cases a good deal of one-on-one support and advice. We’re also well on the way to incorporating new, proprietary exercises into the program. This upgrade will be available to existing customers at no additional charge.
Best wishes, and thank you so much for your support,
Martin Walker
martin@mindevolvesoftware.com
Hi Martin,
I’d have sworn I answered earlier, but… nope! Oops.
I think just about everyone in this field/niche has the same ultimate goal of improving people’s brains, and I’ll never understand why some folks think needing to pay expenses and put food on the table is in conflict with that. Ah well!
Oh, and you’re welcome. : )